Side-by-side comparison
New York probate is real, the NY estate-tax cliff is real, and the right answer for your family is usually a will, sometimes both. Here is how to tell.
The quick answer
Will
Required. Cheap. Probated.
Directs your assets after death. Goes through NY Surrogate's Court, typically 9 to 18 months. Public record.
Living Trust
Optional. Pricier. Private.
Holds assets while you are alive and transfers them outside probate. Earns its keep on larger estates and complex situations.
A will directs how your assets get distributed after probate, a court-supervised process that in New York can take 9 to 18 months and incurs filing fees. A revocable living trust holds assets while you are alive and transfers them directly without probate. Most New York families need a will. Some, especially in Westchester or Putnam, also benefit from a trust.
Estate planning conversations in New York start with a question most online articles do not answer well: do I need a will, a trust, or both? The honest answer is that it depends on your asset mix, your family situation, and how much you care about probate avoidance.
New York has its own quirks. A $7.16 million estate-tax exemption with a 5% cliff that can eliminate the exemption entirely. A probate process through Surrogate's Court that typically runs 9 to 18 months. Real-estate that can stay tied up during probate. These details matter when choosing between a will and a trust.
By the numbers
Trusts cost more to set up but bypass NY probate entirely for assets titled to the trust.
Illustrative example. Actual figures depend on individual circumstances (age, health, tax bracket, state, carrier) and may differ.
Side by side
| # | Attribute | Will | Living Trust |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goes through probate? | Yes | No (for assets titled in the trust) | |
| Effective when | After death | Immediately, and continues after death | |
| Privacy | Public record once filed | Private | |
| NY probate time | 9 to 18 months typical | Days to weeks | |
| Cost to set up | $500 to $1,500 typical | $2,500 to $5,000+ typical | |
| Ongoing maintenance | Low | Requires retitling assets into the trust | |
| Best fit | Most New York families | Families with real estate in multiple states, privacy concerns, or larger estates |
Noah, our story-world guide
"Every New York family should have at least a will, a healthcare proxy, and a durable power of attorney. The trust is a layer on top, not a replacement."
Decision rule
Decision rule
The expert take
Peter Guggisberg
Financial Advisor · Hudson Valley, NY
Every Hudson Valley family should have at least a will, healthcare proxy, and durable power of attorney. That covers most situations and keeps your wishes legally enforceable. A revocable living trust earns its keep when the estate is larger, there is out-of-state real estate, or there is a specific structural reason like minor children or special-needs planning. The right answer is to start with the will package, then add a trust if and only if the situation calls for it.
Common questions
Your numbers, your call
The first call is free. Thirty minutes, no pitch, no pressure. Bring whatever you have and we'll see if the work makes sense for your family.
Schedule a free Consultation